Université Clermont Auvergne - UCA vs SKEMA Business School vs EDHEC Business School vs Excelia Business School vs ESSCA School of Management

Side-by-side comparison from 235 verified student reviews. Scan one row at a time — winners are highlighted

Quick verdict
Higher overall rating: Ecole Vatel Bordeaux (4.50)
Université Clermont Auvergne - UCA: wins 3/7 categories
SKEMA Business School: wins 0/7 categories
EDHEC Business School: wins 0/7 categories
Excelia Business School: wins 1/7 categories
ESSCA School of Management: wins 0/7 categories
Ecole Vatel Bordeaux: wins 2/7 categories
RUBIKA: wins 1/7 categories
Comparing
Best programme: Biological Science
Best programme: Supply Chain Management
Best programme: Business Administration in Management
La Rochelle, France
4.30
Read more reviews
23 reviews
×
Best programme: Master of Science (MSc)
Best programme: International Business
Bordeaux, France
4.50
Top
Read more reviews
10 reviews
×
Best programme: Bachelor Program “Operational Manager in International Hospitality” in English (3 years)
Valenciennes, France
4.40
Read more reviews
14 reviews
×
Best programme: 2D Animation
Category ratings
Facilities
5.00
Win
4.20
4.20
4.24
3.57
3.90
4.43
Location
4.25
4.24
3.73
4.27
3.71
4.30
Win
3.14
Professors
4.25
4.41
4.32
4.13
4.14
4.70
Win
4.29
Internationality
4.25
4.36
4.41
4.57
Win
4.29
4.30
3.93
Student life
4.75
Win
4.10
4.14
4.34
4.14
3.78
4.14
Value
4.25
4.04
4.05
4.20
4.00
4.20
4.64
Win
Accommodation
4.50
Win
3.56
3.14
3.74
2.86
3.78
4.29
Pros & Cons
Pros
  • +Engaging and responsive professors
  • +Supportive academic environment and resources
  • +Enriching international student community and diverse programs
  • +International focus and diverse campus experiences
  • +Practical, industry-relevant curriculum and career support
  • +Strong community with great classmates and alumni network
  • +Rigorous academic and practical preparation for careers
  • +Strong alumni network and career services support
  • +International exposure and diverse student body
  • +Supportive, approachable professors and strong emphasis on practical, real-world business applications.
  • +Diverse, international environment fostering personal growth and unforgettable shared experiences.
  • +Opportunities for teamwork, self-discovery, and engaging learning through case studies and projects.
  • +Strong international focus and diverse programs
  • +Excellent networking opportunities and alumni network
  • +Engaging learning environment and helpful professors
  • +Practical and hands-on learning
  • +Study abroad opportunities and international exposure
  • +Professional and passionate professors
  • +Practical project-based learning for career readiness
  • +Supportive instructors from industry
  • +Positive school environment and student well-being focus
Cons
  • -Administrative and management issues cause frustration.
  • -Outdated facilities and resources negatively impact the learning experience.
  • -Lack of communication and unclear expectations are common complaints.
  • -Administrative and management issues create poor student experience.
  • -Ineffective communication and guidance hinder career development.
  • -Faculty and program organization are disappointing and overly focused on profit.
  • -High tuition fees and perceived low return on investment.
  • -Administrative and management issues cause significant frustration.
  • -Outdated facilities and a lack of resources hinder learning.
  • -Poor communication and lack of support from faculty are prevalent complaints.
  • -Irrelevant courses and unqualified instructors are a common complaint.
  • -The high cost of tuition for subpar offerings is a significant detractor.
  • -Inefficient administrative and management processes cause frustration.
  • -Outdated and poorly maintained facilities detract from the learning environment.
  • -Lack of communication and transparency from instructors and the university is a common complaint.
  • -Administrative and management issues cause significant frustration.
  • -Outdated facilities and lack of modern resources are a recurring problem.
  • -Teaching quality and course content are often found to be lacking.
Rating summary
What students say

This institution demonstrates considerable strengths in several key areas, particularly excelling in Student Life with a high rating of 4.75. Facilities also received a perfect score of 5, indicating excellent infrastructure. Conversely, the lowest-rated aspect is Professors, with a score of 4.25, suggesting room for improvement in this domain. Overall, the university presents a well-rounded profile with notable strengths in student experience and facilities.

Across a range of metrics, this institution demonstrates considerable strengths, particularly in its **professors** (4.41) and **internationality** (4.36). Facilities and location also received favorable scores, both above 4.2. Student life and value are rated around 4.0, indicating a generally positive experience. The weakest area is **accommodation**, which stands at 3.56, suggesting room for improvement in this aspect.

Academic and student experience aspects generally receive positive marks, with **Internationality** standing out as the strongest area with a rating of 4.41. Professors and Facilities are also highly rated. Conversely, **Accomodation** presents the weakest area at 3.14, indicating room for improvement in this regard. Location and Student Life are moderately rated, suggesting a solid but not exceptional experience in those domains.

This university garners an impressive average rating of 4.19. Its strongest areas are **Internationality** (4.57) and **Student Life** (4.34), indicating a vibrant and globally connected campus environment. **Facilities** (4.24) and **Location** (4.27) also score very well. The weakest area is **Accomodation**, receiving a rating of 3.74, suggesting room for improvement in this aspect.

This university's strengths lie significantly in its **Internationality**, rated at 4.29, and **Student Life** and **Professors**, both scoring a high 4.14. However, **Accomodation** emerges as the weakest area, with a considerably lower rating of 2.86. Other aspects like Facilities (3.57), Location (3.71), and Value (4) fall within a moderate to good range.

Across various aspects, this institution demonstrates a strong academic reputation. Professors are exceptionally rated at 4.7, with location and internationality also scoring highly at 4.3. Student life and accommodation are similarly rated at approximately 3.78, while facilities present the weakest area with a score of 3.9. Overall, the university offers good value at 4.2.

Overall, this institution excels in areas concerning financial benefit and campus resources. With an impressive **4.64**, "Value" stands out as the highest-rated aspect, closely followed by "Facilities" at **4.43**. Conversely, "Location" received the lowest score at **3.14**, indicating it's the weakest area. Other strong points include "Accomodation" and "Professors," both scoring **4.29**.

Reviews summary
Highlights

All four reviews are positive, with an average rating of 4.25/5. Students frequently praise the helpful and engaging professors, supportive staff, and enriching international student environment. The programs are also highlighted as excellent.

The vast majority (~97%) of reviews are positive, praising international opportunities, practical curriculum, and strong alumni networks. A small percentage (~3%) express concerns about management, communication, and organization.

With a 4.24/5 average, ~98% of reviews are positive, highlighting intense courses, strong alumni networks, and excellent career services. A small percentage of feedback mentioned high tuition fees.

The reviews are overwhelmingly positive (~100%), highlighting excellent professors, practical courses, and a strong international environment. Students appreciate teamwork opportunities and the school's ability to foster personal growth and unforgettable experiences.

~86% of reviews are positive, highlighting international exposure, networking, and good professors. Some negative feedback (~14%) mentioned irrelevant courses and teachers.

All ten reviews are positive, with an average rating of 4.5/5. Students highlight practical, dynamic classes, passionate professors, and beneficial study abroad programs that enhance skills and career prospects. There is no negative feedback.

Reviews are overwhelmingly positive (~93% of feedback) with an average rating of 4.36/5. Students highlight excellent, industry-professional instructors, a focus on project-based learning, and supportive environments.

Rating distribution
5★
25%
49%
39%
39%
29%
50%
43%
4★
75%
42%
52%
61%
43%
50%
50%
3★
0%
7%
9%
0%
14%
0%
7%
2★
0%
2%
2%
0%
14%
0%
0%
1★
0%
2%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
Most useful review
Most liked

Nothing to show

Experience in School

My experience in SKEMA Business School is very much enriching. It definitely help me to shape my career aspirations which align with my personal value and even worldview. The management system in my university quite efficient and systematic. Every year, we, students are required to give personal feedback on our learning and courses for each semesters. It is very helpful as it could assist my university to improve its lacking in every aspects.

Enriching Experience

I absolutely love everything about EDHEC, beginning from the pedagogy to the atmosphere it provides to the students (especially international) on campus. The extracurricular activities like sports, associations are very helpful. Also, the career service provided is top-notch. Therefore, I would call it an enriching experience so far.

Nothing to show

Engaging

ESSCA School of Management is known for its international approach and diverse programs. In my opinion, many students appreciate its emphasis on experiential learning and the opportunities for international exposure through exchange programs and internships. However, some may find the workload demanding and challenging but that's the way it operates. Whether I recommend it would depend on your specific academic and career goals, as well as your preferences for learning style and environment. Likes/ Dislikes: *Essca provides enormous opportunities to improve and enhance your skill. *Diversified culture *Provides webinars and seminars across all the campuses. *Workload Management could be seen as an disadvantage. As sometimes, you may find it very challenging.

Valuable networking

I found a tight-knit community at Ecole Vatel, with valuable networking and experiential learning opportunities. The intimate setting allows professors to tailor their guidance, equipping students with applicable knowledge and skills. This personalized approach motivated me to reach my full potential and feel better about transitioning into the workforce.

Nothing to show

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our Privacy Policy for more details.
Close