Heriot-Watt University - HW vs SKEMA Business School vs Middlesex University - MDX vs EM Normandie - EM Normandie vs Curtin University

Side-by-side comparison from 623 verified student reviews. Scan one row at a time — winners are highlighted

Quick verdict
Higher overall rating: Tie
Heriot-Watt University - HW: wins 0/6 categories
SKEMA Business School: wins 1/6 categories
Middlesex University - MDX: wins 0/6 categories
EM Normandie - EM Normandie: wins 0/6 categories
Curtin University: wins 2/6 categories
Heriot-Watt University Dubai: wins 0/6 categories
TETR College of Business: wins 3/6 categories
Comparing
Edinburgh, The United Kingdom
4.00
Read more reviews
210 reviews
×
Best programme: Accounting and Finance
Best programme: Supply Chain Management
London, The United Kingdom
4.20
Read more reviews
161 reviews
×
Best programme: Accounting and Finance
Best programme: MSc International Logistics and Port Management
Perth, Australia
4.40
Read more reviews
35 reviews
×
Best programme: Accounting and Finance
Dubai, United Arab Emirates
4.20
Read more reviews
43 reviews
×
Best programme: Accounting and Finance
New York City, United States
4.40
Read more reviews
5 reviews
×
Best programme: Bachelor of Management & Technology
Category ratings
Facilities
3.86
4.21
4.25
4.13
4.42
Win
4.31
4.33
Location
3.46
4.23
4.06
3.75
4.06
4.41
4.67
Win
Professors
4.09
4.39
Win
4.26
4.13
4.29
4.16
4.25
Internationality
3.78
4.40
4.23
4.13
4.38
4.19
4.50
Win
Student life
3.79
4.14
4.19
3.63
4.33
4.21
4.33
Value
3.85
4.07
4.06
4.13
4.41
Win
4.05
4.25
Accommodation
3.61
3.59
3.65
3.57
3.88
3.40
4.50
Win
Pros & Cons
Pros
  • +Practical, employability-focused courses
  • +Supportive and accessible staff
  • +Welcoming and accommodating environment
  • +Industry-focused learning with practical skills and career opportunities
  • +International environment and diverse student body
  • +Quality of teaching and faculty expertise
  • +Practical, relevant, and industry-standard course content
  • +Passionate, supportive, and approachable lecturers
  • +Diverse, inclusive, and vibrant campus community
  • +Practical, industry-relevant courses and inspiring professors
  • +Rich international environment and diverse student body
  • +Personal and professional development opportunities
  • +Practical, hands-on learning and skill development
  • +Industry-relevant curriculum and experienced faculty
  • +Strong global reputation and graduate employment satisfaction
  • +Expert and approachable faculty.
  • +Well-structured, relevant programs with practical focus.
  • +Supportive environment and excellent facilities.
  • +Experiential learning and business creation
  • +Industry leader insights and networking opportunities
  • +Diverse international environment and impactful outcomes
Cons
  • -Lack of meaningful academic support and engaging teaching.
  • -Inadequate facilities and resources, particularly for practical learning and career development.
  • -Poor administrative and management issues leading to disorganization and staff disrespect.
  • -Administrative and management issues with communication, exam, and results handling.
  • -Perceived focus on financial gain over student welfare and education.
  • -Unhelpful or discriminatory faculty and poor academic program organization.
  • -Administrative and management issues are a recurring problem.
  • -Outdated facilities and a lack of resources are frequently mentioned.
  • -Course content and teaching methods are often criticized as being ineffective.
  • -Financial concerns and perceived low educational value.
  • -Inefficient and unhelpful administrative processes.
  • -Lack of engagement and poor communication from instructors.
  • -Outdated resources and uninspiring learning environments.
  • -Irrelevant or unhelpful degree programs.
  • -Disorganized and unresponsive administration.
  • -Outdated and poorly maintained facilities.
  • -Unengaging and ineffective teaching methods.
Rating summary
What students say

Academic and student life aspects of the university are generally well-regarded. Professors receive the highest rating at 4.09, indicating a strong area. Conversely, location scores the lowest at 3.46, suggesting it's the weakest point. Other areas like facilities, student life, accommodation, internationality, and value all fall within a moderate to good range.

This institution garners strong evaluations, particularly in its **Professors** and **Internationality**, both scoring above 4.3. **Facilities**, **Location**, and **Student Life** also receive commendable marks, all exceeding 4.1. **Value** sits just above 4.0. The area with the lowest score is **Accomodation**, averaging 3.59.

Surveyed metrics indicate a generally positive university experience. Professors and Internationality received the highest marks, both above 4.2. Facilities and Student Life also scored well, exceeding 4.1. Location and Value were rated respectably around 4.0. The weakest area, Accommodation, scored significantly lower at 3.6.

This institution garners excellent marks in several key areas. Facilities, Professors, Internationality, and Value all received high scores of 4.125. Student Life and Accommodations are rated lower, at 3.625 and approximately 3.57 respectively, indicating these are areas with more room for improvement compared to its other strengths. The Location score sits at 3.75.

This institution receives high marks in several key areas, with **Facilities** and **Value** standing out as its strongest performers. **Student Life**, **Internationality**, and **Professors** also earned very positive reviews. The university's **Location** is rated well, though not as highly as its top-scoring categories. **Accommodations** received the lowest score among the surveyed aspects, indicating a potential area for improvement.

This institution garners strong positive feedback, particularly in its location (4.41), which stands out as its highest-rated aspect. Facilities also receive high marks (4.31). However, accommodation presents a notable area for improvement, scoring the lowest at 3.4. Other categories like professors, student life, and internationality are all rated well above average, with value also being a positive indicator.

This institution garners strong overall evaluations, with location standing out as the highest-rated aspect at 4.67. Accommodations and internationality also received excellent scores of 4.5. Areas demonstrating solid performance include facilities and student life, both at 4.33, alongside value and professors, which are rated at 4.25.

Reviews summary
Highlights

Nearly 74% of reviews are positive, praising employability skills, good professors, and accommodating staff. A small ~1.9% of feedback is negative, citing lack of teaching support and confusion regarding course material.

Approximately 97.5% of reviews are positive, praising opportunities, industry links, and diverse student life. A small percentage of negative feedback mentions poor management and communication.

With a 4.24 average rating from 161 reviews, ~89% of feedback is positive. Students praise practical course content, passionate lecturers, and a good campus vibe. No negative reviews were recorded.

Most reviews praise the inspiring professors, practical learning, and international environment, contributing to a ~74% positive sentiment. One review expressed dissatisfaction, calling it a money-making scheme with mediocre teaching.

University reviews are overwhelmingly positive (~92% of feedback), with students praising experienced faculty and practical, industry-relevant curriculum. There is minimal negative feedback.

Approximately 97.7% of 43 reviews are positive, highlighting inspiring expert professors, a nurturing campus environment, and enriching academic and personal growth. A small percentage of feedback noted some modules felt outdated and a need for campus expansion.

With an average rating of 4.4/5 from 5 reviews, students are highly satisfied. Recurring positive themes include practical, hands-on learning experiences and valuable networking opportunities. A minimal amount of feedback noted occasional scheduling issues with tutoring.

Rating distribution
5★
27%
50%
35%
38%
46%
33%
60%
4★
51%
42%
53%
38%
49%
60%
20%
3★
20%
7%
11%
13%
6%
5%
20%
2★
1%
1%
0%
0%
0%
2%
0%
1★
0%
1%
0%
13%
0%
0%
0%
Most useful review
Most liked
The campus

Love Heriot Watt! I’ve been studying in the Dubai campus and I’ve now transferred to the Edinburgh one and it’s amazing! The campus has many useful facilities and there always creative events taking place for students to interact.

Class of 2018, Int'l Business Administration

Studying at Skema Business School in Sophia Antipolis was a fantastic experience. The campus is modern and located in a wonderful tech hub. The professors bring real-world business experience to the classroom. I loved the multicultural environment and the group projects. Skema gave me great friends, a strong global network, and the right skills for my career.

teachers

most teachers are very patient when helping and explaining to student with questions, the time table planning is not great, responsible team is only accepting online request which the reply was always unable to make changes(except health related issues )

Nothing to show

Career-supportive!

Curtin University is greta for those who are very "career-centric"; the university itself places great emphasis on how to find internships and jobs and are very supportive in that regard. The university is also one that places importance on social networking, whether that be through clubs, discord servers and affordable or free social events. One thing I do dislike however is the disorganisation in some courses or how little spaces there can be for classes (this might be specific to my major/course though). Overall I have enjoyed my time here so far.

Nothing to show

Loving it here!

Being here has been such a wild ride. Moving to a new country every semester and learning local languages has been both fun and challenging, but it's kinda exhausting too. Still, that hustle gives me an adrenaline rush I low-key love! The best part has been seeing our business ideas come to life and when people genuinely appreciate and engage with something we’ve built, it makes all the hard work worth it.

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our Privacy Policy for more details.
Close