IÉSEG School of Management vs SKEMA Business School vs Excelia Business School vs ESSCA School of Management vs Sciences Po Saint-Germain

Side-by-side comparison from 447 verified student reviews. Scan one row at a time — winners are highlighted

Quick verdict
Higher overall rating: Sciences Po Saint-Germain (4.70)
IÉSEG School of Management: wins 0/7 categories
SKEMA Business School: wins 0/7 categories
Excelia Business School: wins 2/7 categories
ESSCA School of Management: wins 0/7 categories
Sciences Po Saint-Germain: wins 2/7 categories
Schiller International University: wins 2/7 categories
Ecole Vatel Bordeaux: wins 1/7 categories
Comparing
Best programme: Programme Grande Ecole (PGE)
Best programme: Supply Chain Management
La Rochelle, France
4.30
Read more reviews
24 reviews
×
Best programme: Master of Science (MSc)
Best programme: International Business
Saint-Germain-En-Laye, France
4.70
Top
Read more reviews
3 reviews
×
Best programme: Political Science
Tampa, Florida, United States
4.50
Read more reviews
13 reviews
×
Best programme: BA International Relations and Diplomacy
Bordeaux, France
4.50
Read more reviews
10 reviews
×
Best programme: Bachelor Program “Operational Manager in International Hospitality” in English (3 years)
Category ratings
Facilities
4.09
4.21
4.27
3.50
4.33
Win
3.92
3.90
Location
4.29
4.24
4.30
4.21
3.00
4.92
Win
4.30
Professors
4.28
4.42
4.12
4.00
4.33
4.62
4.70
Win
Internationality
4.55
4.35
4.58
4.00
4.33
4.92
Win
4.30
Student life
4.25
4.12
4.34
Win
4.15
3.00
4.15
3.78
Value
4.31
4.04
4.19
3.79
4.33
Win
4.23
4.20
Accommodation
3.78
3.59
3.79
Win
3.14
3.00
3.62
3.78
Pros & Cons
Pros
  • +Engaging and practical learning experiences
  • +Strong international community and global opportunities
  • +Supportive professors and active student associations
  • +Practical, career-focused programs and skill development
  • +Engaging student life and impactful associations
  • +Strong academic faculty and international opportunities
  • +Supportive, approachable professors and practical, relevant coursework
  • +Strong international environment and diverse student community
  • +Numerous opportunities for personal and professional development
  • +Practical, real-world learning and professional connections
  • +International and diverse environment
  • +High-quality teaching and modern facilities
  • +International environment and diverse perspectives
  • +High-quality teaching and supportive faculty
  • +Small class sizes and administrative support
  • +Culturally diverse environment and international campus access
  • +Supportive and organized academic environment with helpful instructors
  • +Opportunities for career advancement and independent learning
  • +Practical and hands-on learning
  • +Study abroad opportunities and international exposure
  • +Professional and passionate professors
Cons
  • -Last-minute changes disrupt scheduling and planning.
  • -Perceived lack of effort to improve classroom experience.
  • -Concerns about course offerings and professor quality.
  • -Poor administrative and management issues, including communication and exam organization.
  • -Focus on profit over student well-being and discriminatory practices.
  • -Unorganized program structure and overwhelming course load.
  • -Outdated facilities and insufficient resources.
  • -Poor communication and disorganized administrative processes.
  • -Lack of effective teaching and unsupportive instructors.
  • -Irrelevant courses and unqualified teachers.
  • -High cost for low value.
  • -Administrative and management issues are a recurring problem.
  • -Outdated facilities and lack of modern resources are a concern.
  • -Poor communication and lack of responsiveness from staff are frustrating.
  • -Lack of extracurriculars and limited opportunities for lower-year students.
  • -Poor campus environment and a perceived low academic standard.
  • -Inefficient administrative and management processes cause frustration.
  • -Outdated and poorly maintained facilities detract from the learning environment.
  • -Lack of communication and transparency from instructors and the university is a common complaint.
Rating summary
What students say

This university receives high marks across most categories, particularly excelling in **Internationality** (4.55). **Location** (4.29), **Student Life** (4.25), and **Value** (4.31) also demonstrate considerable strengths. Conversely, **Accomodation** (3.78) stands out as the weakest area among the assessed aspects, while **Facilities** (4.09) received a solid, yet comparatively lower, rating.

This university receives high marks for its professors and internationality, with ratings of 4.42 and 4.35 respectively. Location and facilities are also well-regarded, both scoring above 4.2. Student life and value are rated around 4.0, indicating solid performance. The weakest area is accommodation, which receives a score of 3.59.

This institution receives top marks for its Internationality, scoring an impressive 4.58. Student Life and Location also rank highly at 4.34 and 4.3 respectively. While Facilities and Value are also strong with scores above 4.1, Accomodation stands out as the weakest area, receiving a rating of 3.79.

This institution demonstrates strong performance in its **location** and **student life**, both receiving high marks. It also fares well in **professors** and **internationality**. Conversely, **accommodation** emerges as the weakest area, with the lowest rating. **Facilities** and **value** are rated moderately.

This institution garners excellent reviews for its **Facilities**, **Professors**, **Internationality**, and **Value**, all scoring a high 4.33. Conversely, **Location**, **Student Life**, and **Accomodation** received a more moderate rating of 3. This indicates a university excelling in academic and resource-driven aspects, while areas related to the surrounding environment and student experience present opportunities for improvement.

With a strong emphasis on location and internationality, this university also scores very well for its professors and student life. Value for money is also a positive aspect. The weakest areas, while still respectable, are its facilities and accommodation.

Across various aspects, this institution demonstrates a strong academic reputation. Professors are exceptionally rated at 4.7, with location and internationality also scoring highly at 4.3. Student life and accommodation are similarly rated at approximately 3.78, while facilities present the weakest area with a score of 3.9. Overall, the university offers good value at 4.2.

Reviews summary
Highlights

With a 4.38/5 average, ~99% of reviews are positive, praising interesting classes, international experiences, and practical preparation for work. A minimal 0.8% of feedback is negative, citing some course content and last-minute changes.

Approximately 90% of reviews are positive, highlighting great teachers, valuable student associations, and international opportunities. A small fraction of negative feedback, around 3%, mentions concerns with management, communication, and organization.

With a ~100% positive sentiment across 24 reviews, students praise Excelia for its amazing school environment, incredible people, and supportive teachers. They highlight teamwork, countless opportunities, and a strong international atmosphere.

Approximately 74% of reviews are positive, highlighting a good experience with practical teaching, international environments, and valuable professional connections. A small portion (~7%) expressed concerns about course relevance and cost.

With an average rating of 4.67/5, ~100% of feedback is positive. Students praise the international program, high-quality professors, and opportunities for analytical thinking. The supportive environment and small class sizes are also frequently highlighted.

With a 4.54/5 average rating, nearly all students praise Schiller for its culturally rich environment and global opportunities. A small portion of feedback (~7.7%) suggests the university may be better suited for those seeking a less demanding academic path.

All ten reviews are positive, with an average rating of 4.5/5. Students highlight practical, dynamic classes, passionate professors, and beneficial study abroad programs that enhance skills and career prospects. There is no negative feedback.

Rating distribution
5★
49%
49%
38%
29%
67%
69%
50%
4★
44%
42%
63%
43%
33%
23%
50%
3★
9%
7%
0%
21%
0%
0%
0%
2★
0%
1%
0%
7%
0%
8%
0%
1★
0%
1%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
Most useful review
Most liked
A formative and enriching experience

IÉSEG offers interactive teaching and international opportunities. I had the chance to go on an exchange to another country, which opened up new perspectives for me. The courses in Lille are stimulating, and the professors are very involved in our success.

Experience in School

My experience in SKEMA Business School is very much enriching. It definitely help me to shape my career aspirations which align with my personal value and even worldview. The management system in my university quite efficient and systematic. Every year, we, students are required to give personal feedback on our learning and courses for each semesters. It is very helpful as it could assist my university to improve its lacking in every aspects.

Nothing to show

Engaging

ESSCA School of Management is known for its international approach and diverse programs. In my opinion, many students appreciate its emphasis on experiential learning and the opportunities for international exposure through exchange programs and internships. However, some may find the workload demanding and challenging but that's the way it operates. Whether I recommend it would depend on your specific academic and career goals, as well as your preferences for learning style and environment. Likes/ Dislikes: *Essca provides enormous opportunities to improve and enhance your skill. *Diversified culture *Provides webinars and seminars across all the campuses. *Workload Management could be seen as an disadvantage. As sometimes, you may find it very challenging.

Nothing to show

The cultural mix and the great atmosphere.

I loved being at Schiller in Heidelberg. The setting and the city were very serene and the exposure to all those students and teachers from such different and diverse backgrounds was a great learning experience. Additionally, the ease of accessing the Schiller campuses in the other countries was a great additional bonus to studying at Schiller. I would most definitely recommend Schiller to other students who are looking for a very culturally fulfilling experience.

Valuable networking

I found a tight-knit community at Ecole Vatel, with valuable networking and experiential learning opportunities. The intimate setting allows professors to tailor their guidance, equipping students with applicable knowledge and skills. This personalized approach motivated me to reach my full potential and feel better about transitioning into the workforce.

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our Privacy Policy for more details.
Close