emlyon business school vs Heriot-Watt University - HW vs SKEMA Business School vs Manipal Academy of Higher Education - MAHE - MU vs TAPMICEL

Side-by-side comparison from 575 verified student reviews. Scan one row at a time — winners are highlighted

Quick verdict
Higher overall rating: TETR College of Business (4.50)
emlyon business school: wins 0/7 categories
Heriot-Watt University - HW: wins 0/7 categories
SKEMA Business School: wins 0/7 categories
Manipal Academy of Higher Education - MAHE - MU: wins 0/7 categories
TAPMICEL: wins 0/7 categories
Sikkim Manipal University: wins 0/7 categories
TETR College of Business: wins 7/7 categories
Comparing
Best programme: Programme Grande Ecole (PGE)
Edinburgh, The United Kingdom
4.00
Read more reviews
211 reviews
×
Best programme: Accounting and Finance
Best programme: Business Administration
Best programme: Dental Surgery
Manipal, India
Not rated
Read more reviews
0 reviews
×
New York City, United States
4.50
Top
Read more reviews
6 reviews
×
Best programme: Bachelor of Management & Technology
Category ratings
Facilities
4.16
3.87
4.23
4.12
Not rated
Not rated
4.40
Win
Location
4.54
3.49
4.32
3.91
Not rated
Not rated
4.60
Win
Professors
4.05
4.09
4.37
4.13
Not rated
Not rated
4.50
Win
Internationality
4.56
3.79
4.43
3.17
Not rated
Not rated
4.67
Win
Student life
4.24
3.81
4.25
4.30
Not rated
Not rated
4.60
Win
Value
4.40
3.85
4.09
3.96
Not rated
Not rated
4.50
Win
Accommodation
3.94
3.62
3.70
3.68
Not rated
Not rated
4.50
Win
Pros & Cons
Pros
  • +Practical, international, and globally-minded programs with diverse student body.
  • +Strong focus on professional development through internships and career support.
  • +Rich program offerings with opportunities for personal and academic growth.
  • +Practical, employability-focused courses
  • +Supportive and accessible staff
  • +Welcoming and accommodating environment
  • +Practical skills and real-world business application
  • +International environment and diverse experiences
  • +Career development and professional growth
  • +Diverse student body and global community
  • +Strong academic programs and industry-relevant knowledge
  • +Supportive faculty and excellent placement support

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

  • +Practical, real-world business experience and skill development.
  • +Unique global mobility and diverse cultural immersion opportunities.
  • +Valuable industry connections and strong peer networking.
Cons
  • -Lack of practical learning and perceived filler content.
  • -Unfair and frustrating grading, especially for group projects.
  • -Poor professor engagement and program support.
  • -Lack of meaningful academic support and engaging teaching.
  • -Inadequate facilities and resources, particularly for practical learning and career development.
  • -Poor administrative and management issues leading to disorganization and staff disrespect.
  • -Administrative & management issues
  • -Poor communication and guidance
  • -Outdated facilities and teaching faculty
  • -High tuition fees and poor job placement rates are a major concern.
  • -Limited and often damaged recreational facilities detract from the student experience.
  • -The university offers a poor value for money regarding services provided.

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

  • -Administrative and management issues cause frustration.
  • -Facilities are outdated and poorly maintained.
  • -Communication from the institution is frequently unclear or lacking.
Rating summary
What students say

Reviewing the provided ratings, the institution demonstrates notable strengths in **Internationality** and **Location**, both receiving scores above 4.5. Conversely, **Accomodation** emerged as the area with the lowest rating, falling below 4.0. Other categories, including Facilities, Professors, Student Life, and Value, all scored commendably, generally ranging between 4.05 and 4.4.

Academic and student life aspects of the university are generally well-regarded. Professors receive the highest rating at 4.09, indicating a strong area. Conversely, location scores the lowest at 3.46, suggesting it's the weakest point. Other areas like facilities, student life, accommodation, internationality, and value all fall within a moderate to good range.

Across surveyed categories, this institution demonstrates robust strengths in **Internationality (4.43)** and **Professors (4.37)**. Student life, location, and facilities also received positive scores. However, **Accomodation** stands out as the lowest-rated area at **3.70**, suggesting potential room for improvement in that specific aspect. The overall value is also rated favorably at 4.09.

This university demonstrates notable strengths in **Student Life**, boasting a high rating. Areas such as **Facilities** and **Professors** also receive favorable scores. Conversely, **Internationality** and **Accomodation** are identified as areas with lower ratings, suggesting potential for improvement in these aspects. The university presents a mixed but generally positive outlook across its evaluated components.

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

This institution demonstrates a consistently strong performance across key areas. It excels particularly in **Internationality**, **Student Life**, and **Location**, all receiving top marks. **Facilities**, **Professors**, and **Accomodation** also score highly. The **Value** proposition is well-regarded. While all ratings are impressive, the slight difference in scores suggests that the unique global atmosphere, vibrant campus experience, and convenient setting are standout features.

Reviews summary
Highlights

The vast majority of reviews (around 98%) are positive, praising the program's academic rigor, international environment, and career support. A small percentage of feedback (about 2%) expressed disappointment with limited practical learning and grading fairness.

Nearly 74% of reviews are positive, praising employability skills, good professors, and accommodating staff. A small ~1.9% of feedback is negative, citing lack of teaching support and confusion regarding course material.

With a 4.37/5 average rating from 175 reviews, approximately 97.7% of students provide positive feedback. Key highlights include practical skills, international opportunities, and professional development. A small percentage of negative feedback mentions poor management and organization.

With a 4.11/5 average rating from 128 reviews, ~83% praise the university for its diverse student body, supportive environment, and robust academic programs. A small minority (~0.8%) found it expensive with limited recreational facilities and placements.

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

Most student reviews are highly positive, with ~83% rating 4-5 stars and an average of 4.5/5. Recurring themes include brilliant concepts, learning by doing, and valuable real-world business experience. Minimal negative feedback was noted.

Rating distribution
5★
58%
27%
50%
29%
0%
0%
67%
4★
29%
51%
41%
54%
0%
0%
17%
3★
11%
20%
7%
16%
0%
0%
17%
2★
0%
1%
1%
1%
0%
0%
0%
1★
2%
0%
1%
0%
0%
0%
0%
Most useful review
Most liked

Nothing to show

The campus

Love Heriot Watt! I’ve been studying in the Dubai campus and I’ve now transferred to the Edinburgh one and it’s amazing! The campus has many useful facilities and there always creative events taking place for students to interact.

Class of 2018, Int'l Business Administration

Studying at Skema Business School in Sophia Antipolis was a fantastic experience. The campus is modern and located in a wonderful tech hub. The professors bring real-world business experience to the classroom. I loved the multicultural environment and the group projects. Skema gave me great friends, a strong global network, and the right skills for my career.

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

Loving it here!

Being here has been such a wild ride. Moving to a new country every semester and learning local languages has been both fun and challenging, but it's kinda exhausting too. Still, that hustle gives me an adrenaline rush I low-key love! The best part has been seeing our business ideas come to life and when people genuinely appreciate and engage with something we’ve built, it makes all the hard work worth it.

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our Privacy Policy for more details.
Close