McGill University vs Université de Montréal vs John Abbott College vs College CDI vs TAV College

Side-by-side comparison from 159 verified student reviews. Scan one row at a time — winners are highlighted

Quick verdict
Higher overall rating: Tie
McGill University: wins 0/1 categories
Université de Montréal: wins 0/1 categories
John Abbott College: wins 0/1 categories
College CDI: wins 0/1 categories
TAV College: wins 0/1 categories
RUBIKA: wins 0/1 categories
Polytechnique Montréal: wins 1/1 categories
Comparing
Montreal, Canada
4.40
Read more reviews
106 reviews
×
Best programme: Psychology
Best programme: Political Science
Montreal, Canada
5.00
Read more reviews
1 reviews
×
Best programme: Engineering Technologies
Montreal, Canada
Not rated
Read more reviews
0 reviews
×
Montreal, Canada
4.00
Read more reviews
1 reviews
×
Best programme: Business and Digital Marketing
Valenciennes, France
4.40
Read more reviews
15 reviews
×
Best programme: 2D Animation
Best programme: Information Technology
Category ratings
Facilities
4.23
4.29
5.00
Not rated
5.00
4.47
5.00
Location
4.76
4.15
5.00
Not rated
5.00
3.13
5.00
Professors
4.29
4.29
4.00
Not rated
5.00
4.27
5.00
Internationality
4.67
4.09
4.00
Not rated
4.00
3.87
5.00
Win
Student life
4.55
4.06
5.00
Not rated
5.00
4.20
5.00
Value
4.38
4.11
3.00
Not rated
5.00
4.67
5.00
Accommodation
3.92
3.79
3.00
Not rated
5.00
4.33
5.00
Pros & Cons
Pros
  • +Engaging and well-structured academic programs.
  • +Dedicated and accessible professors.
  • +Supportive and interactive learning environment.
  • +Engaging and knowledgeable professors
  • +Diverse and challenging coursework
  • +Hands-on learning and research opportunities
  • +Excellent facilities and a positive, historic campus atmosphere.
  • +High-quality teaching and engaging, challenging academic programs.
  • +Vibrant campus life with numerous extracurricular activities.

Nothing to show

  • +Teaching excellence and faculty dedication
  • +Interactive and engaging learning environment
  • +Personalized attention and academic success
  • +Industry-active instructors and professional preparation
  • +Supportive and welcoming atmosphere
  • +Emphasis on practical, project-based learning
  • +Expert and dedicated professors
  • +Vibrant student life
Cons
  • -Overcrowded classes and limited professor interaction.
  • -Outdated curriculum and lack of real-world application in courses.
  • -Unrealistic workload and emphasis on memorization.
  • -Administrative and management issues cause frustration and inefficiency.
  • -Outdated facilities and resources hinder learning experiences.
  • -Lack of clear communication and support leaves students feeling lost.
  • -Outdated facilities and poor maintenance are a common complaint.
  • -Inefficient administrative processes and lack of support are frequently mentioned.
  • -Lack of practical application and career relevance in coursework is a recurring concern.

Nothing to show

  • -Administrative and management issues cause frequent problems.
  • -Outdated facilities and a lack of resources are common complaints.
  • -Poor communication and lack of support from staff create frustration.
  • -Administrative and management issues cause frequent problems.
  • -Facilities are frequently described as outdated and in poor condition.
  • -Teaching quality and curriculum relevance are inconsistent and often disappointing.
  • -Administrative & management issues create confusion and frustration.
  • -Outdated facilities negatively impact the learning environment.
  • -Lack of effective communication leads to unmet student expectations.
Rating summary
What students say

University evaluations show a strong showing in several key areas, with Location and Internationality receiving particularly high scores. Student Life and Value also stand out positively. The weakest area identified is Accomodation, indicating room for improvement in this specific aspect of the university experience, while Facilities and Professors are rated solidly in the upper range.

Evaluations indicate a generally positive university experience. Facilities and Professors received the highest marks, with strong scores also noted for Location and Value. Student Life and Internationality also performed well. Accommodations stand out as the lowest-rated area, though still receiving a respectable score. Overall, the university presents a solid offering across most aspects of student life and academics.

This institution excels in several key areas, boasting perfect scores for **Facilities** and **Location**, alongside a strong showing in **Student Life**. However, areas for improvement are apparent in **Accomodation** and **Value**, both receiving a rating of 3. Ratings for **Professors** and **Internationality** fall in the upper-mid range.

Nothing to show

Overall, the university demonstrates exceptionally strong performance across most surveyed aspects. It received perfect scores in Facilities, Professors, Location, Student Life, Accomodation, and Value. The weakest area, while still positive, is Internationality, rated at a commendable 4. This suggests a highly desirable institution with outstanding offerings in nearly every dimension, with a slight opportunity for enhanced global engagement.

This institution demonstrates exceptional strengths in its **Value** (4.67) and **Facilities** (4.47), indicating high satisfaction in these key areas. **Accomodation** (4.33) and **Student Life** (4.20) also received positive scores. However, the university's **Location** (3.13) stands out as a comparatively weaker aspect, with **Internationality** (3.87) also receiving a moderate rating.

Across all surveyed categories, this institution received perfect scores. Facilities, professors, location, student life, accommodation, internationality, and perceived value were all rated a maximum of 5 out of 5. The university demonstrates exceptional strength in every area evaluated, with no particular category standing out as weaker than others given the uniformly high marks.

Reviews summary
Highlights

The overwhelming majority of university students praise professors' dedication, well-structured and interactive courses, and abundant resources. A very small percentage mention overcrowded classes and a disconnect between some course content and real-world application.

Nearly all reviews are positive, highlighting knowledgeable and engaging professors, a wide course variety, and supportive university personnel. A strong interaction between instructors and students is frequently mentioned.

The single review is overwhelmingly positive, giving a 5/5 rating. It highlights an amazing campus with good facilities, new library, and great buildings. Teachers were also praised, though a discrepancy in program difficulty was noted.

Nothing to show

With a single review, this university received a 4/5 average rating. The feedback was entirely positive, highlighting teaching excellence and a dynamic learning environment.

With a 4.4/5 average rating from 15 reviews, ~93% are positive. Students praise quality teaching from industry professionals and a supportive, welcoming atmosphere. The heavy workload and project-focused curriculum prepare them well for professional careers.

With a 5/5 average rating and 100% positive feedback, students praise competent professors and a vibrant student life. No negative reviews were submitted.

Rating distribution
5★
54%
34%
100%
0%
0%
47%
100%
4★
36%
60%
0%
0%
100%
47%
0%
3★
8%
6%
0%
0%
0%
7%
0%
2★
2%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
1★
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
Most useful review
Most liked
The accessibility

As a current student at McGill University, my experience has been incredibly rewarding both academically and personally. McGill is known for its strong international reputation, and it truly lives up to that with a diverse student body from around the world, which creates an exciting, global learning environment. The academic programs are challenging and research-driven, which pushes you to think critically and manage your time effectively. I’ve particularly appreciated the interdisciplinary opportunities, allowing me to combine Political Science, International Development, and South Asian Studies, and learn from professors who are passionate leaders in their fields. Beyond the classroom, campus life is vibrant, with countless clubs, events, and networking opportunities, plus the unique experience of living in Montréal, a city that balances culture, affordability, and excitement. If there’s one area for improvement, it would be student support services. While resources are available, they can sometimes feel stretched, especially during peak academic periods, and navigating administrative processes can be challenging. Overall, I would absolutely recommend McGill to anyone looking for a rigorous education in an inspiring, multicultural setting with strong global recognition.

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our Privacy Policy for more details.
Close