SKEMA Business School vs University of St. Thomas vs St. Catherine University vs Macalester College vs Schiller International University

Side-by-side comparison from 176 verified student reviews. Scan one row at a time — winners are highlighted

Quick verdict
Higher overall rating: Tie
SKEMA Business School: wins 0/3 categories
University of St. Thomas: wins 0/3 categories
St. Catherine University: wins 3/3 categories
Macalester College: wins 0/3 categories
Schiller International University: wins 0/3 categories
St Cloud State University - STC: wins 0/3 categories
TETR College of Business: wins 0/3 categories
Comparing
Best programme: Supply Chain Management
Saint Paul, Minnesota, United States
5.00
Read more reviews
3 reviews
×
Best programme: Electrical and Computer Engineering
Saint Paul, Minnesota, United States
5.00
Read more reviews
1 reviews
×
Best programme: Nursing
Saint Paul, Minnesota, United States
4.40
Read more reviews
18 reviews
×
Best programme: Nursing
Tampa, Florida, United States
4.50
Read more reviews
13 reviews
×
Best programme: BA International Relations and Diplomacy
Saint Paul, Minnesota, United States
4.00
Read more reviews
2 reviews
×
Best programme: Education Management
New York City, United States
5.00
Read more reviews
3 reviews
×
Best programme: Bachelor of Management & Technology
Category ratings
Facilities
4.21
4.33
5.00
Win
4.25
3.92
4.00
4.50
Location
4.24
2.33
5.00
Win
3.61
4.92
4.50
4.50
Professors
4.42
4.33
5.00
4.50
4.62
4.50
5.00
Internationality
4.35
4.67
5.00
4.61
4.92
4.50
5.00
Student life
4.12
2.67
5.00
4.39
4.15
4.50
5.00
Value
4.04
4.33
5.00
4.44
4.23
4.50
5.00
Accommodation
3.59
3.00
5.00
Win
4.29
3.62
4.50
4.50
Pros & Cons
Pros
  • +Practical, career-focused programs and skill development
  • +Engaging student life and impactful associations
  • +Strong academic faculty and international opportunities
  • +Advanced lab facilities and research centers
  • +Strong theoretical and practical learning balance
  • +Knowledgeable, supportive, and approachable professors
  • +Experienced & practicing professors
  • +Early and extensive clinical experience
  • +Rigorous and supportive academic environment
  • +Outstanding and dedicated faculty.
  • +Strong sense of community and inclusivity.
  • +Abundant resources and engagement opportunities.
  • +Culturally diverse environment and international campus access
  • +Supportive and organized academic environment with helpful instructors
  • +Opportunities for career advancement and independent learning
  • +Comprehensive program options and strong student support
  • +Accessible and helpful transition assistance
  • +Experiential learning and entrepreneurship opportunities
  • +Direct access to industry leaders (CXOs, CEOs)
  • +Valuable networking and lifelong friendships
Cons
  • -Poor administrative and management issues, including communication and exam organization.
  • -Focus on profit over student well-being and discriminatory practices.
  • -Unorganized program structure and overwhelming course load.
  • -Unresponsive administrative and management issues plague students.
  • -Outdated facilities and poor technology hinder learning experiences.
  • -Inconsistent and unclear communication causes confusion.
  • -Administrative and management issues disrupt student experience.
  • -Outdated facilities and resources hinder learning and comfort.
  • -Lack of effective communication and support leaves students feeling ignored.
  • -Administrative and management issues cause frequent problems.
  • -Outdated facilities and technology hinder learning.
  • -Lack of student support and communication is a recurring concern.
  • -Lack of extracurriculars and limited opportunities for lower-year students.
  • -Poor campus environment and a perceived low academic standard.
  • -Administrative and management issues are a recurring frustration.
  • -Outdated facilities and equipment hinder learning.
  • -Lack of clear communication and support impacts student experience.
  • -Administrative and management issues are a major frustration.
  • -Outdated facilities and lack of essential resources are common complaints.
  • -Poor communication and lack of transparency from the institution are frequently mentioned.
Rating summary
What students say

This university receives high marks for its professors and internationality, with ratings of 4.42 and 4.35 respectively. Location and facilities are also well-regarded, both scoring above 4.2. Student life and value are rated around 4.0, indicating solid performance. The weakest area is accommodation, which receives a score of 3.59.

This institution excels in **Internationality**, earning a score of 4.67. Its **Facilities**, **Professors**, and **Value** are also highly rated, all coming in at 4.33. Conversely, **Location** and **Student Life** represent the university's weaker aspects, with scores of 2.33 and 2.67 respectively. **Accommodation** falls in the middle with a rating of 3.

Across all surveyed categories, this institution has achieved perfect scores. Its strengths lie in every aspect, from its top-tier facilities and outstanding professors to its vibrant student life and ideal location. Furthermore, accommodation, internationality, and overall value are all rated exceptionally highly. No weakest areas were identified, indicating a consistently excellent experience for students.

This university garners strong marks across several key areas. Internationality stands out as its highest-rated category. Students also report positive experiences with Professors, Student Life, Value, and Accommodations. Facilities are rated well, though slightly lower than these top performers. Location, while still a decent score, represents the weakest aspect of the university's profile according to these ratings.

With a strong emphasis on location and internationality, this university also scores very well for its professors and student life. Value for money is also a positive aspect. The weakest areas, while still respectable, are its facilities and accommodation.

An analysis of university ratings reveals a predominantly strong performance across several key areas. The institution excels with perfect scores in Student Life, Accommodation, Internationality, and Value, alongside a high rating for its Location. Professors also received an excellent mark of 4.5. Facilities represent the weakest area, though still rated highly at 4.

Across a range of metrics, the university demonstrates exceptional strengths, particularly in its Professors, Student Life, Internationality, and overall Value, all receiving perfect scores. Location, Facilities, and Accommodations also stand out with high ratings. While no specific area received a low score, the consistency across the board suggests a well-rounded institution with particularly strong offerings in teaching quality and student experience.

Reviews summary
Highlights

Approximately 90% of reviews are positive, highlighting great teachers, valuable student associations, and international opportunities. A small fraction of negative feedback, around 3%, mentions concerns with management, communication, and organization.

All three reviews were positive, giving a 5/5 average rating. Students highlighted world-class lab facilities, including advanced microgrid research, and a strong curriculum balancing theory and hands-on learning. Professors were described as knowledgeable and supportive.

This review is overwhelmingly positive, with a 5/5 average rating from 100% positive feedback. Students highlighted knowledgeable and experienced professors and early clinical opportunities.

With ~100% positive feedback and an average rating of 4.44/5, students highlight outstanding professors, abundant resources, and a strong sense of community. Small class sizes foster deep connections, and diverse campus events offer ample skill-building and networking opportunities.

With a 4.54/5 average rating, nearly all students praise Schiller for its culturally rich environment and global opportunities. A small portion of feedback (~7.7%) suggests the university may be better suited for those seeking a less demanding academic path.

With a 4/5 average rating, ~100% of feedback is positive. Students praise the institution's excellent and customized programs, along with strong support from application to enrollment.

All three reviews are highly positive, averaging 5/5 stars. Students highlight real-world business experience, including product development and profit generation, and valuable learning from industry leaders. They also praise opportunities for international collaboration and lifelong friendships.

Rating distribution
5★
49%
100%
100%
44%
69%
50%
100%
4★
42%
0%
0%
56%
23%
0%
0%
3★
7%
0%
0%
0%
0%
50%
0%
2★
1%
0%
0%
0%
8%
0%
0%
1★
1%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
Most useful review
Most liked
Experience in School

My experience in SKEMA Business School is very much enriching. It definitely help me to shape my career aspirations which align with my personal value and even worldview. The management system in my university quite efficient and systematic. Every year, we, students are required to give personal feedback on our learning and courses for each semesters. It is very helpful as it could assist my university to improve its lacking in every aspects.

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

The cultural mix and the great atmosphere.

I loved being at Schiller in Heidelberg. The setting and the city were very serene and the exposure to all those students and teachers from such different and diverse backgrounds was a great learning experience. Additionally, the ease of accessing the Schiller campuses in the other countries was a great additional bonus to studying at Schiller. I would most definitely recommend Schiller to other students who are looking for a very culturally fulfilling experience.

Nothing to show

Loving it here!

Being here has been such a wild ride. Moving to a new country every semester and learning local languages has been both fun and challenging, but it's kinda exhausting too. Still, that hustle gives me an adrenaline rush I low-key love! The best part has been seeing our business ideas come to life and when people genuinely appreciate and engage with something we’ve built, it makes all the hard work worth it.

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our Privacy Policy for more details.
Close