IÉSEG School of Management vs emlyon business school vs Excelia Business School vs The New School vs ESSCA School of Management

Side-by-side comparison from 413 verified student reviews. Scan one row at a time — winners are highlighted

Quick verdict
Higher overall rating: Forward College (4.90)
IÉSEG School of Management: wins 0/6 categories
emlyon business school: wins 0/6 categories
Excelia Business School: wins 0/6 categories
The New School: wins 0/6 categories
ESSCA School of Management: wins 0/6 categories
Forward College: wins 6/6 categories
Ecole des Ponts Business School: wins 0/6 categories
Comparing
Best programme: Programme Grande Ecole (PGE)
Best programme: Programme Grande Ecole (PGE)
La Rochelle, France
4.10
Read more reviews
57 reviews
×
Best programme: Master of Science (MSc)
Paris, France
4.00
Read more reviews
7 reviews
×
Best programme: Accounting
Best programme: Programme Grande Ecole (PGE)
Paris, France
4.90
Top
Read more reviews
16 reviews
×
Best programme: Politics and International Relations
Best programme: AI in Project Management
Category ratings
Facilities
4.08
4.15
4.02
3.83
3.77
4.47
Win
4.33
Location
4.29
4.60
4.28
5.00
4.21
5.00
4.50
Professors
4.28
4.06
3.93
4.29
3.88
5.00
Win
4.80
Internationality
4.55
4.60
4.33
4.43
3.92
4.75
Win
4.60
Student life
4.25
4.25
4.29
3.33
4.16
4.73
Win
4.33
Value
4.31
4.43
4.03
3.86
3.73
4.63
Win
4.00
Accommodation
3.78
3.94
3.61
2.83
3.42
4.33
Win
3.00
Pros & Cons
Pros
  • +Engaging and practical learning experiences
  • +Strong international and diverse community
  • +Opportunities for personal and professional growth
  • +Practical and international programs with diverse students
  • +Valuable professional experience through internships and work-study
  • +Supportive environment for personal and professional development
  • +High-quality teaching from professors and speakers
  • +International environment and student diversity
  • +Practical curriculum and preparation for professional challenges
  • +Personalized, adaptable programs and learning
  • +Supportive, engaging faculty and staff
  • +Vibrant city environment with opportunities
  • +Quality education and specialized pathways
  • +Vibrant campus life and student activities
  • +Practical experience and professional connections
  • +Engaging learning environment with interactive methods
  • +Diverse and international student community
  • +Unique multi-city European study experience
  • +Strong career advancement and market-relevant skills.
  • +High-quality faculty and engaging curriculum.
  • +Welcoming community and supportive staff.
Cons
  • -Frequent last-minute changes disrupt scheduling and planning.
  • -Perceived lack of effort to improve the classroom experience.
  • -Concerns about course offerings and professor quality.
  • -Lack of practical value and shallow content in courses.
  • -Unfair and frustrating grading, especially for group projects.
  • -Disappointing professor engagement and program support.
  • -Superficial academic content lacking depth and practical value
  • -Unprofessional training and insufficient internship/apprenticeship support
  • -Courses not aligning with student expectations or desired specializations
  • -Administrative & management issues cause significant frustration.
  • -Outdated facilities hinder the learning experience.
  • -Limited career support and networking opportunities are a concern.
  • -Poor teaching quality and unhelpful professors
  • -Disorganized administration and irrelevant course content
  • -High cost for unengaging and outdated programs
  • -Administrative & management issues cause frustration.
  • -Outdated facilities and equipment are a concern.
  • -Lack of transparency and communication is prevalent.
  • -Administrative and management issues cause frustration.
  • -Outdated facilities and poor upkeep are prevalent.
  • -Lack of resources and support hinder academic progress.
Rating summary
What students say

This institution demonstrates notable strengths in several key areas, with Internationality receiving the highest score. Location and Value also received very favorable ratings. Conversely, Accomodation emerged as the area with the lowest score, indicating room for improvement in this aspect of the student experience. Overall, the university presents a compelling offering across most dimensions.

This institution demonstrates exceptional strength in its internationality and location, both scoring above 4.5. Student life and value also received positive marks, exceeding 4.2 and 4.4 respectively. However, accommodation presents as the weakest area, with the lowest rating of approximately 3.94. Facilities and professors also received solid, though slightly lower, scores in comparison.

This university exhibits a generally positive rating profile. Its strongest areas are Internationality, closely followed by Student Life and Location, all receiving high scores above 4.2. Conversely, Accomodation stands out as the weakest category, with the lowest rating of 3.61. Other aspects like Facilities, Professors, and Value fall within a solid mid-range, indicating areas of consistent, good performance.

This institution scores exceptionally well in **Internationality** and **Location**, both receiving high marks. **Professors** are also highly rated. Conversely, **Accomodation** received the lowest score, indicating an area for potential improvement. **Student Life** and **Facilities** are rated moderately, while **Value** sits in a similar range.

Assessing the university's performance reveals distinct strengths and areas for improvement. The location stands out with the highest rating, closely followed by student life. Accommodation, however, presents the lowest score, indicating a potential area requiring attention. Other metrics, including facilities, professors, internationality, and value, fall within a mid-range, demonstrating a generally solid but not exceptional performance.

This university garners excellent reviews, particularly excelling in its **professors and location**, both achieving perfect scores. Student life and internationality also stand out with scores above 4.7. Areas with slightly lower, though still strong, ratings include **facilities and accommodation**. Overall, the university presents a well-rounded positive student experience with high marks across most aspects.

This university garners exceptional scores in academic and social aspects, with Professors receiving a near-perfect 4.8 and Internationality a strong 4.6. Facilities and Student Life are also well-regarded at 4.33. Location and Value are solid at 4.5 and 4 respectively. However, Accomodation stands out as a weaker area, scoring a significantly lower 3.

Reviews summary
Highlights

Overwhelmingly positive feedback, with ~91% of reviews being 4-5 stars and an average rating of 4.38/5. A small ~0.8% expressed concerns about learning outcomes and last-minute changes.

The vast majority of university students have a positive experience, highlighting academic rigor, practical learning, and international environments. A small fraction of reviews mention disappointment with course content and grading.

Most reviews are positive (~86%), praising teaching quality, cultural diversity, and modern infrastructure. A small number (~5%) mention superficial subject coverage or lack of practical value.

With a 4/5 average rating, ~74% of reviews are positive, highlighting fulfilling academic experiences and strong communities. Negative feedback is minimal, with no 1-2 star reviews.

Most reviews are positive (~74%), highlighting good knowledge transfer, specialization options, practical experience, and a vibrant campus life. A small portion of negative feedback (~8%) mentions unprepared professors and organizational issues.

Students highly praise the interactive learning, international community, and opportunities for academic and personal growth. There are no negative reviews.

With 100% positive sentiment, student reviews highlight strong career advancement and valuable skills gained. Frequent themes include high-quality courses, competent professors, and practical relevance. Some students desired stronger post-graduation support and a more engaged alumni network.

Rating distribution
5★
49%
60%
33%
29%
31%
94%
40%
4★
44%
28%
54%
43%
46%
6%
60%
3★
8%
9%
9%
29%
15%
0%
0%
2★
0%
0%
4%
0%
4%
0%
0%
1★
0%
2%
2%
0%
4%
0%
0%
Most useful review
Most liked
A formative and enriching experience

IÉSEG offers interactive teaching and international opportunities. I had the chance to go on an exchange to another country, which opened up new perspectives for me. The courses in Lille are stimulating, and the professors are very involved in our success.

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

Well-rounded programme

Overall, I had a positive experience at ESSCA. The programme is well organized and provides a solid foundation in business and management. The courses were generally of good quality and covered a broad range of topics, helping students develop both academic knowledge and practical skills. One of the aspects I appreciated most was the international exchange during the third year. ESSCA has a good network of partner universities, and the opportunity to study abroad was a valuable part of the programme. Student life is also a real strength of the school. The associative environment is active and offers many opportunities to get involved outside the classroom, meet new people, and gain additional experience. Like any programme, some courses were more engaging than others, but overall I found the experience enriching and would recommend it to students looking for a business school with a strong international dimension and a good balance between academics and extracurricular activities.

Great modern university approach

I am currently a 3rd year student at Forward College and I have thoroughly enjoyed the experience and would recommend it to other students. The interactive approach of Forward where questions, debate, and discussion were encouraged enhanced my learning so much and I feel like I genuinely enjoyed every class. Having the experience of living in 3 different cultures, surrounded by people from all over the world made this experience even more special and helped me develop and grow in so many ways. Another aspect I have loved are the professors. Speaking with friends at other university I am so grateful to have teachers that actually know us, are excited to teach and interact with us, and will always take the time to help you.

Nothing to show

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our Privacy Policy for more details.
Close