The University of Adelaide vs Flinders University vs Torrens University Australia vs Carnegie Mellon University vs Melbourne Business School

Side-by-side comparison from 85 verified student reviews. Scan one row at a time — winners are highlighted

Quick verdict
Higher overall rating: Melbourne Business School (5.00)
The University of Adelaide: wins 0/5 categories
Flinders University: wins 0/5 categories
Torrens University Australia: wins 0/5 categories
Carnegie Mellon University: wins 0/5 categories
Melbourne Business School: wins 4/5 categories
Roffey Park Institute: wins 0/5 categories
Kaplan Business School: wins 1/5 categories
Comparing
Adelaide, Australia
4.30
Read more reviews
30 reviews
×
Best programme: Computer Science
Adelaide, Australia
4.20
Read more reviews
35 reviews
×
Best programme: Accounting
Best programme: Hospitality Management
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, United States
4.30
Read more reviews
8 reviews
×
Best programme: Applied Arts and Science
Melbourne, Australia
5.00
Top
Read more reviews
2 reviews
×
Best programme: Business and Marketing
Horsham, Australia
Not rated
Read more reviews
0 reviews
×
Adelaide, Australia
4.50
Read more reviews
2 reviews
×
Best programme: Business
Category ratings
Facilities
4.32
4.12
3.38
4.38
5.00
Not rated
5.00
Location
4.50
4.25
3.63
4.50
4.00
Not rated
5.00
Win
Professors
4.46
4.31
3.38
4.13
5.00
Not rated
5.00
Internationality
4.46
3.83
3.50
4.38
5.00
Win
Not rated
4.50
Student life
4.26
3.83
3.00
4.38
5.00
Win
Not rated
4.50
Value
4.25
4.14
3.38
4.25
5.00
Win
Not rated
4.50
Accommodation
3.68
3.63
3.17
4.25
5.00
Win
Not rated
Not rated
Pros & Cons
Pros
  • +Excellent academics, supervision, and research opportunities.
  • +Strong infrastructure, well-equipped facilities, and good student life.
  • +Applicable learning experiences and career-focused education.
  • +Supportive and approachable professors building personal connections
  • +Peaceful, picturesque, and welcoming campus environment conducive to study
  • +Inclusive community with diverse opportunities and readily accessible resources
  • +Engaging and interactive classes with knowledgeable and passionate professors
  • +Flexible learning options catering to working students
  • +Practical, real-world experience emphasized
  • +Challenging yet supportive academic environment with excellent professors.
  • +Diverse and high-achieving student body fostering connections and collaboration.
  • +Well-structured courses with real-world applications and encouraging critical thinking.
  • +Life-changing educational experience and career readiness
  • +Supportive community and valuable peer connections
  • +Excellent study environment and resources

Nothing to show

  • +Flexible online program structure
  • +Supportive and approachable faculty
  • +Excellent teaching quality
Cons
  • -Administrative and management issues create significant frustration.
  • -Outdated facilities and a lack of resources hinder the learning experience.
  • -Poor communication and lack of support from staff are major concerns.
  • -Administrative and management issues cause frustration.
  • -Outdated facilities and equipment hinder learning.
  • -Lack of clear communication and support is a concern.
  • -Administrative and management issues like course changes and unclear enrollment practices.
  • -High costs and questionable value for money regarding tuition fees.
  • -Inconsistent quality of teaching staff and potentially rude or untrained facilitators.
  • -Administrative and management issues are a significant source of frustration.
  • -Outdated facilities and a lack of essential resources are frequently criticized.
  • -The curriculum and teaching methods are often perceived as irrelevant or ineffective.
  • -Outdated facilities and poor maintenance are a recurring problem.
  • -Lack of clear communication and administrative inefficiencies cause frustration.
  • -The curriculum is perceived as unengaging and disconnected from real-world applications.

Nothing to show

  • -Administrative and management issues cause significant frustration.
  • -Outdated facilities and technology are a major drawback.
  • -Lack of effective communication and unclear expectations are common complaints.
Rating summary
What students say

This institution garners particularly high marks for its **Location** (4.5) and **Professors** and **Internationality**, both scoring 4.46. Student experience is well-regarded, with strong showings in **Student Life** (4.26) and **Value** (4.25). The university's **Accomodation** (3.68) is its lowest-rated aspect. Facilities also received a solid, though not exceptional, score of 4.32.

This institution receives strong marks in several key areas, with professors achieving the highest rating at 4.31. Facilities and value are also rated highly, both around 4.1. Student life, internationality, and accommodation fall in the mid-range, with accommodation being the lowest rated at 3.63. Overall, the university demonstrates a solid academic and resource-based offering.

This institution demonstrates strengths in its **Location**, receiving the highest rating. Conversely, **Student Life** stands out as the area requiring the most attention, with the lowest score. Other aspects like Facilities, Professors, and Value are rated similarly and fall in the mid-range. Accomodation and Internationality also received respectable, though slightly lower, scores compared to the strongest category.

This university demonstrates a strong profile, with its **location** standing out as the highest-rated aspect. Facilities, student life, and internationality all received excellent scores, indicating robust offerings in these areas. While professors, accommodation, and value also scored well, they represent the university's comparatively weaker, though still positive, performance.

This institution receives outstanding marks across the board, with perfect scores awarded for facilities, professors, student life, accommodation, internationality, and value. Its only slight deviation from a perfect score is in location, which still garners a very respectable rating. The university's strengths are clearly in its comprehensive offerings and student experience.

Nothing to show

This institution boasts exceptional strengths in its **Facilities, Professors, and Location**, all receiving a perfect score of 5. The **Student Life** and **Internationality** are also highly regarded at 4.5. However, a significant weakness is evident in **Accommodations**, which scored a zero, indicating a considerable area for improvement. The overall **Value** is rated well at 4.5.

Reviews summary
Highlights

Most reviews are highly positive (~87% 4-5 stars), praising excellent academics, supervision, and research opportunities. Students highlight good infrastructure and supportive staff, with no negative feedback observed.

With an average rating of 4.17/5, nearly all ~100% of feedback is positive. Students praise knowledgeable, supportive professors and a welcoming, picturesque campus. Resources and facilities are also highlighted as superb.

~63% of reviews are positive, praising flexible learning, passionate professors, and engaging classes. ~37.5% of feedback is negative, citing course changes and high costs.

Approximately 88% of reviews are positive, highlighting diverse minds, engaging coursework, and supportive environments. There are no negative reviews.

With an average rating of 5/5, reviews are overwhelmingly positive. Students highlight life-changing experiences, strong support systems, quality education, and career readiness. They also appreciate university events, study spaces, and library resources.

Nothing to show

With an average rating of 4.5/5, feedback is overwhelmingly positive (~100% of reviews). Students highlight excellent teaching quality, approachable professors, and the rewarding, flexible nature of online programs.

Rating distribution
5★
43%
20%
38%
38%
100%
0%
50%
4★
43%
77%
25%
50%
0%
0%
50%
3★
13%
3%
0%
13%
0%
0%
0%
2★
0%
0%
13%
0%
0%
0%
0%
1★
0%
0%
25%
0%
0%
0%
0%
Most useful review
Most liked
Excellent University

With three options for Universities within South Australia, I would highly recommend The University of Adelaide! I studied there for 6 years, completing a Bachelor's and an Honours degree, and began a PhD that I ended up withdrawing from due to personal reasons. My time at the University was excellent, with knowledgeable professors and tutors, up-to-date and well-equipped laboratories and computer suites, and a fun student life with clubs of varying interests and events happening across campus. While finding information for abnormal requests, such as majoring in a topic from a different degree or transferring to a brand new degree at the University, was difficult on my own, there was always someone to help at the student help desks. Even when I had to withdraw from my PhD program, the faculty were understanding and helped walk me through the process of leaving the program. The University is also in the top 100 universities in the world, and part of Australia's Group of Eight, comprising of Australia's leading research-intensive universities. I would highly recommend studying here.

Nothing to show

Torrens university

I want to share my experience with Torrens University. They initially gave me an offer letter and Confirmation of Enrollment (COE), but after I had been in the course for a year, they changed the name of the course and added more subjects to my study plan. It really feels like Torrens is using this format to make more money from students. This kind of practice is frustrating and makes it hard for us to plan our studies effectively.

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our Privacy Policy for more details.
Close