University of the Punjab - PU vs University of Management and Technology - UMT vs University of South Asia - USA vs Kinnaird College for Women University - KCWU vs Skans School of Accountancy - Nil

Side-by-side comparison from 160 verified student reviews. Scan one row at a time — winners are highlighted

Quick verdict
Higher overall rating: University of South Asia - USA (4.90)
University of the Punjab - PU: wins 0/7 categories
University of Management and Technology - UMT: wins 0/7 categories
University of South Asia - USA: wins 6/7 categories
Kinnaird College for Women University - KCWU: wins 0/7 categories
Skans School of Accountancy - Nil: wins 0/7 categories
Lahore Garrison University: wins 1/7 categories
National College of Business Administration and Economics: wins 0/7 categories
Comparing
Best programme: Chemistry and Chemical Engineering
Best programme: Computer Science
Best programme: Health Science
Best programme: BA (hons) Social Sciences
Best programme: Accounting and Finance
Best programme: Applied Computer Science
Best programme: Bachelor of Business Administration
Category ratings
Facilities
4.18
3.56
4.69
Win
4.40
4.00
3.50
3.00
Location
4.66
3.39
4.80
4.80
3.67
5.00
Win
3.67
Professors
4.42
4.00
4.73
Win
4.20
3.67
4.50
3.67
Internationality
3.92
3.50
4.55
Win
4.20
3.33
3.50
2.67
Student life
4.29
3.56
4.67
Win
4.20
3.67
4.00
3.00
Value
4.35
3.89
4.67
Win
4.60
3.67
4.00
3.33
Accommodation
3.92
3.22
4.62
Win
4.60
4.00
3.00
2.67
Pros & Cons
Pros
  • +Strong academic programs with knowledgeable and supportive faculty
  • +Vibrant campus atmosphere with diverse opportunities and engaging learning environment
  • +Affordable student city with practical experience and career development support
  • +Diverse programs and dedicated, approachable faculty
  • +Engaging campus life and student support
  • +Holistic development and transformative experiences
  • +Supportive faculty and practical, skill-focused learning
  • +Positive campus atmosphere and environment
  • +Effective teaching tailored to student understanding
  • +Prestigious reputation and worldwide recognition
  • +High-quality faculty and competitive peer group
  • +Broad and in-depth academic programs
  • +Knowledgeable and passionate instructors
  • +Suitable program recommendations
  • +Professional environment
  • +Excellent IT and Computer Science programs
  • +Strong career outcomes and job placement
  • +Positive campus environment with good facilities and active societies
  • +Expert faculty & outcome-based education
  • +Engaging professors & strong class participation
  • +Cooperative administration & good infrastructure
Cons
  • -Administrative and management issues, particularly with the IT and exam branches, are a major source of frustration.
  • -Lack of transparency, merit, and reliance on connections for support are significant concerns.
  • -Outdated facilities and unmotivated staff contribute to a negative learning environment.
  • -Administrative and management issues cause a lack of action on student requests.
  • -Frequent and unjustified fee increases are a major concern.
  • -Some teachers lack fundamental subject knowledge.
  • -Administrative and management issues are a consistent problem.
  • -Facilities are often described as outdated and poorly maintained.
  • -Lack of resources and support significantly hinders learning.
  • -Outdated facilities and poor maintenance are frequent complaints.
  • -Inefficient administrative processes and lack of clear communication are major frustrations.
  • -Limited access to resources and support services create significant difficulties.
  • -Administrative and management issues are a significant concern.
  • -Outdated facilities and a lack of resources hinder learning.
  • -Poor communication and unclear expectations lead to frustration.
  • -Administrative and management issues are a significant source of frustration.
  • -Outdated facilities and a lack of modern resources are frequently criticized.
  • -Course content is often perceived as irrelevant or poorly structured.
  • -Administrative and management issues, including poor student-teacher communication and lack of career counseling.
  • -Limited co-curricular activities and a general lack of student engagement opportunities.
  • -Unhelpful faculty members, with very few exceptions.
Rating summary
What students say

Consistently strong performance marks this institution's review, with location achieving the highest rating at 4.66. Professors also received excellent marks at 4.42, followed closely by student life and value. Accommodations presented the lowest score at 3.92, with internationality also falling below the 4.0 threshold, indicating areas for potential improvement within the university's offerings.

This institution shows its strongest performance in value for money, alongside positive ratings for professors and student life. Facilities and internationality also receive solid scores. However, areas such as location and accommodation fall slightly below the average, indicating potential for improvement in these aspects.

This institution receives overwhelmingly positive feedback from students, with its **Location** standing out as the highest-rated aspect. **Professors** also garnered exceptionally strong reviews. While still impressive, **Internationality** presented the lowest score among the evaluated categories. Overall, the university demonstrates a consistently strong performance across all surveyed areas.

This institution garners impressive scores across the board. Its location stands out as a particular strength, receiving the highest rating. Areas like accommodation and facilities also perform very well. Student life, professors, and internationality are rated solidly. The value proposition is also quite strong.

This university demonstrates notable strengths in its facilities and accommodation, both receiving high marks. Its location, student life, and value for money are also well-regarded, averaging a solid 3.67. The weakest area identified is internationality, which scores slightly lower than other aspects. Overall, the university presents a generally positive profile with specific areas of excellence.

An examination of the university's ratings reveals a strong emphasis on its prime **location**, scoring a perfect 5. Professors also received high marks at 4.5. Areas for potential improvement include **accommodation**, which received a score of 3, representing the lowest rating. Other aspects such as student life, internationality, and value fall within a solid range, indicating a generally well-rounded institution.

This university shows a mixed performance in its ratings. Its strongest areas are Professors and Location, both scoring an average of 3.67. Conversely, Accomodation and Internationality are its weakest points, each receiving a score of 2.67. Facilities and Student Life also averaged a moderate 3, while Value sits slightly above average at 3.33.

Reviews summary
Highlights

Approximately 71 out of 80 reviews are positive, highlighting strong academics, knowledgeable faculty, and an energetic campus environment. A small percentage of feedback notes issues with university management.

Most students (~74%) report a vibrant atmosphere with dedicated faculty, diverse programs, and engaging campus life. A small percentage (~11%) noted issues with subject teacher knowledge and administrative management.

With a 4.86/5 average, virtually all (~100%) of 49 reviews are positive. Students praise the enriching experience, knowledgeable and supportive faculty, and practical curriculum. The welcoming campus and vibrant atmosphere are also highlighted.

With an average rating of 4.2/5, reviews are overwhelmingly positive (~100% of feedback). Students praise the university's prestige, reputation, quality faculty, and the competitive yet enriching academic environment.

With a high average rating of 4.67/5, 100% of feedback is positive. Students praise professors' strong subject knowledge and passion, and appreciate personalized program recommendations that align with budget and facilities.

With a 4/5 average rating from two reviews, feedback is ~100% positive. Students praise well-educated teachers, good courses, and campus facilities, particularly for IT programs. Event organizations and student societies are also highlighted positively.

Around 67% of reviews are positive, highlighting good faculty, infrastructure, and an engaging learning environment. Approximately 33% of feedback mentioned unhelpful faculty and a lack of career counseling and co-curricular activities.

Rating distribution
5★
63%
33%
88%
40%
67%
0%
33%
4★
26%
33%
10%
40%
33%
100%
33%
3★
9%
22%
2%
20%
0%
0%
0%
2★
1%
6%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
1★
1%
6%
0%
0%
0%
0%
33%
Most useful review
Most liked
About Education system

Im saira students of university of the Punjab i complete my Bs Economics recently i like my university education systems because they give opportunities and chance of needed students of Pakistan and others countries to complete education through funds and scholarships

Doctor Of Pharmacy

I think UMT provides a good learning environment with modern facilities and a strong focus on professional development. The faculty is supportive, and there are plenty of opportunities for growth. However, the fee structure can be a bit high for some students.

Best Computer Science Department

This University has best computer science department they provide all facilities and the teachers are just so amazing. The campus life is fantastic. They have great societies for everything and have fascinating events.

Extravagantly designed and taught course-framework

Studying at Kinnaird College had been a privilege of a lifetime. Not only you get the best of the teachers on campus but also you will be seated among the most competitive girls from around the country. The administration makes sure to maintain top merit for girls that helps them to become high achievers. Kinnaird has the only campus on Jail Road that reminisced about the British Colonial Rule as was constructed by the Britishers during the Indo-Pak rule. Its historic and beautiful building is accompanied by the coolest contemporary cafes and utilities that make it a perfect combo of amusement and study. Kinnaird is the only college and university for girls offering a Master in Philosophy in International Relations after PU and LUMS. All of the doctorates with remarkable contributions in their subjects help you to become a subject matter expert on IR through their extravagant teaching skills. They will guide you through the generic concepts and will then ask you to make detailed assignments on the allocated topics. These brainstorming exercises will help you demonstrate wider dimensions of the topics given, thereby teachers make discussions on the home assignments in the next class to amplify each student’s opinion. I greatly recommend studying at this University as it not only ticks all the boxes to help girls develop their prospective future but is also great for their personal development.

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our Privacy Policy for more details.
Close