Ilmenau University of Technology vs University of Hildesheim vs EM Strasbourg Business School vs Carleton University vs Tidar University - Untidar

Side-by-side comparison from 167 verified student reviews. Scan one row at a time — winners are highlighted

Quick verdict
Higher overall rating: Tie
Ilmenau University of Technology: wins 0/5 categories
University of Hildesheim: wins 2/5 categories
EM Strasbourg Business School: wins 1/5 categories
Carleton University: wins 0/5 categories
Tidar University - Untidar: wins 2/5 categories
Comparing
Best programme: Media and Communications Science
Hildesheim, Germany
5.00
Read more reviews
1 reviews
×
Best programme: Translation
Best programme: Programme Grande Ecole (PGE)
Ottawa, Canada
4.30
Read more reviews
124 reviews
×
Best programme: BA (hons) Psychology
Best programme: Education
Category ratings
Facilities
4.00
5.00
Win
3.90
4.23
4.00
Location
3.30
3.00
4.36
4.28
5.00
Win
Professors
4.18
5.00
4.17
4.20
5.00
Internationality
3.91
3.00
4.30
Win
4.29
4.00
Student life
3.50
3.00
4.00
4.04
5.00
Win
Value
3.91
5.00
Win
4.17
4.33
4.00
Accommodation
4.60
5.00
3.90
4.11
5.00
Pros & Cons
Pros
  • +Highly qualified and supportive professors and strong research opportunities.
  • +Affordable living costs and low tuition fees.
  • +Well-structured programs with modern facilities and industry connections.
  • +Professional, helpful, dedicated teachers and useful classes
  • +Strong program reputation
  • +International focus and diverse student body
  • +Supportive and engaging faculty
  • +Dynamic student life and activities
  • +Critical thinking and analytical skill development
  • +Supportive professors and faculty guidance
  • +Inclusive and diverse campus environment
  • +Scenic, comfortable environment
  • +Focus on entrepreneurship
Cons
  • -Administrative and management issues cause significant delays.
  • -Poor professor availability and slow responses hinder progress.
  • -Administrative and management issues cause significant frustration.
  • -Outdated facilities and resources hinder learning.
  • -Lack of clarity and support from instructors is a recurring problem.
  • -Outdated facilities and poor maintenance are a frequent concern.
  • -Administrative and management issues cause frustration.
  • -Lack of resources and support hinders learning.
  • -Administrative and management issues lead to a poor overall experience.
  • -Facilities are outdated and not well-maintained.
  • -Administrative and management issues cause frequent problems.
  • -Outdated facilities and lack of essential resources are a constant source of frustration.
  • -Poor communication and lack of support negatively impact student experience.
Rating summary
What students say

With a strong showing in several key areas, this institution excels in **Accommodation**, receiving a near-perfect score of 4.6. Professors and Facilities also garnered positive marks, both at 4.0 and above. Conversely, **Location** emerged as the lowest-rated aspect at 3.3. Internationality and Value are rated similarly, indicating a solid overall offering with a notable strength in on-campus living.

This institution receives excellent scores for its **Facilities**, **Professors**, and **Accomodation**, all earning a perfect 5 out of 5. Student life and internationality, however, are rated moderately at 3, suggesting these areas could be further developed. Location also scores a 3. Overall, the university offers exceptional value, mirroring its top marks in key on-campus resources.

A review of university ratings reveals a well-rounded institution. The strongest aspects appear to be Location and Internationality, both scoring above 4.3. Professors and Value are also highly rated, at 4.17. Areas for potential improvement include Facilities and Accomodation, which received scores of approximately 3.9. Student Life sits at a solid 4.

Analyzing university ratings reveals a generally positive reception. The institution excels in **Internationality** (4.29) and **Value** (4.33), indicating strong global connections and perceived worth. **Location** (4.28) and **Facilities** (4.23) also received high marks. The **Student Life** category (4.04) is the weakest area, though still within a generally favorable range.

This institution garners exceptional scores in several key areas, notably achieving perfect marks for its professors, location, student life, accommodation, and overall student experience. Facilities and internationality received strong, though slightly lower, ratings of 4 out of 5. The value proposition also stands at a solid 4, indicating a generally positive and well-rounded university offering.

Reviews summary
Highlights

With ~82% positive reviews and an average rating of 4/5, students praise strong research, innovative professors, and affordability. A small portion (~9%) of feedback mentions coordination issues and difficulties in securing master's thesis topics.

The single review is overwhelmingly positive, rating the university 5/5. Students highlight useful classes, professional and dedicated teachers, and the university's strong reputation. No negative feedback was provided.

Students highly praise the university's international environment, supportive professors, and dynamic student life. Approximately 83% of feedback is positive, with no negative reviews.

Overwhelmingly positive feedback (approximately 89%) highlights strong analytical skill development and engaging program content. A small percentage (~2%) of reviews expressed general dissatisfaction, citing a lack of passion or unmet expectations.

This university received a single review, rating it a perfect 5/5. The positive feedback highlighted its scenic small-town location and comfortable cool climate, conducive to learning. The university also emphasizes entrepreneurship with required courses.

Rating distribution
5★
36%
100%
40%
37%
100%
4★
45%
0%
43%
52%
0%
3★
9%
0%
17%
9%
0%
2★
0%
0%
0%
2%
0%
1★
9%
0%
0%
0%
0%
Most useful review
Most liked

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

Glad I got into the "University of Last Hope"

I look back at my time at Carleton University with much fondness and nostalgia. I pursued my Bachelor of Commerce with a major in Accounting between 2010-14. The faculty were knowledgeable and approachable which made learning easier (and now that I have no deadline worries, somewhat fun). At the time Carleton was still expanding to the sprawling campus it is now, so we had to walk / run fairly far to catch classes. Now even the business program has its own building so I assume classes are more centralised. I was an international student and I loved the diversity and exchange of experiences and opinions at Carleton. No matter the subject, from Sociology to calculus to language to tax & audit, there was always just as much to learn from peers as from professors. It definitely opened my mind and made me think. The Sprott Business School had an amazing lineup of professors from within academia as well as from the corporate world, blending theory and practice well. The campus is nestled right beside the Rideau river and is a visual treat across all the seasons. Though if we talk about Ottawa, we need to speak to the cold winters and Carleton had an amazing tunnel system that spans the entire campus. You can use any entrance and travel across campus in toasty warmth. The tunnels also have a collection of different shops, vending machines for whatever you may need - along with cozy nooks and bustling junctions so you can spend time between classes recharging or hanging out with friends. Being an international student, Carleton was fairly expensive, though average in tuition costs compared to other universities in Canada. There are limited bursaries and scholarships with strict GPA requirements to retain. These were helpful relative to Canadian tuition but were significantly lower compared to international fees. Another expense was the on-campus restaurant and cafeteria; considering that you have very few options, the prices are quite steep (for a student). Other campuses like the University of Ottawa located downtown have access to a more diverse and competitively priced range of restaurants and eateries. Carleton is accessible via bus or train through Ottawa's public transit system, OC Transpo. The system has deteriotated over time and commute can be a pain point for many (especially during rush hour, in winter, or during exam season). While dormitories are convenient, they can be quite expensive. Off-campus housing near the University (Sunnyside, Prince of Wales, etc.) can be relatively cheaper with options to walk to University (yes, even in winter). I would also like to personally speak to the amazing Muslim Student's Association and prayer space that Carleton has. It enriched my time at the University and gave me fresh appreciation for views, customs and kinship across hundreds of cultures. And it provided me with a space to recharge spiritually in a more personal way, being so far from my own home, family and culture. Unfortunately I cannot speak much to the sporting facilities, but Carleton has some of the best teams in the province (especially for Basketball). Our mascot is Rodney the Raven. Their gym facilities in particular were very nice and access is generally granted with the price of tuition. Lastly, I would like to say that given the opportunity and financial ability, I would love to go back and do a graduate course at Carleton, just to be able to walk through its halls and experience the bustle of school life again. Even though it is endearingly known as the "University of Last Hope," I am grateful that I got a chance to spend my formative youth there.

Nothing to show

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our Privacy Policy for more details.
Close