International School of Management vs Manhattan Institute of Management - MIM vs St. John's University vs Columbia University vs School16

Side-by-side comparison from 102 verified student reviews. Scan one row at a time — winners are highlighted

Quick verdict
Higher overall rating: TETR College of Business (5.00)
International School of Management: wins 1/7 categories
Manhattan Institute of Management - MIM: wins 1/7 categories
St. John's University: wins 0/7 categories
Columbia University: wins 0/7 categories
School16: wins 0/7 categories
Flatiron School: wins 1/7 categories
TETR College of Business: wins 4/7 categories
Comparing
Best programme: Bachelor in Management
New York City, United States
4.10
Read more reviews
10 reviews
×
Best programme: International Business Studies
New York City, United States
4.30
Read more reviews
4 reviews
×
Best programme: Applied Chemistry
New York City, United States
4.40
Read more reviews
73 reviews
×
Best programme: Art and Design
New York City, United States
Not rated
Read more reviews
0 reviews
×
New York City, United States
4.00
Read more reviews
1 reviews
×
Best programme: Business
New York City, United States
5.00
Top
Read more reviews
3 reviews
×
Best programme: Bachelor of Management & Technology
Category ratings
Facilities
4.64
Win
3.90
4.00
4.49
Not rated
4.00
4.50
Location
4.64
4.87
Win
4.50
4.36
Not rated
4.00
4.50
Professors
4.82
4.73
4.25
4.37
Not rated
4.00
5.00
Win
Internationality
4.82
4.85
4.25
4.44
Not rated
4.00
5.00
Win
Student life
4.50
4.01
4.00
4.35
Not rated
4.00
5.00
Win
Value
4.73
4.23
4.25
4.44
Not rated
4.00
5.00
Win
Accommodation
4.64
3.53
3.75
4.22
Not rated
5.00
Win
4.50
Pros & Cons
Pros
  • +Expert professors and quality cohorts
  • +Flexible learning and personalized support
  • +Global exposure and networking opportunities
  • +Diverse international student body and global perspective
  • +Practical career preparation and internship opportunities
  • +Supportive administration and qualified, approachable faculty
  • +Supportive supervisors and accessible postgraduate programs
  • +Abundant student organizations and walkable campus
  • +Helpful staff and faculty for student issues
  • +Supportive and passionate faculty
  • +Diverse and thoughtful food options
  • +Affordable and accessible accommodation

Nothing to show

  • +Supportive, knowledgeable staff and comprehensive curriculum
  • +Strong job placement and career support
  • +Experiential learning and entrepreneurship opportunities
  • +Direct access to industry leaders (CXOs, CEOs)
  • +Valuable networking and lifelong friendships
Cons
  • -Poor communication and administrative issues are common complaints.
  • -Facilities are often described as outdated or in disrepair.
  • -Course content and teaching quality are frequently criticized.
  • -Outdated and repetitive course content.
  • -Program value not justifying the cost.
  • -Lack of natural light in classrooms.
  • -Administrative and management issues
  • -Outdated facilities and equipment
  • -Lack of resources and support
  • -Administrative and management issues cause significant frustration.
  • -Outdated facilities and poor maintenance are major drawbacks.
  • -Lack of clear communication and support from instructors is a recurring problem.

Nothing to show

  • -Administrative and management issues create significant frustration.
  • -Outdated facilities and poor maintenance are a persistent problem.
  • -Communication is frequently unclear and inadequate.
  • -Administrative and management issues are a major frustration.
  • -Outdated facilities and lack of essential resources are common complaints.
  • -Poor communication and lack of transparency from the institution are frequently mentioned.
Rating summary
What students say

This institution garners exceptional praise, particularly for its professors and international student experience, both scoring a near-perfect 4.82. Facilities, location, and accommodation also received strong marks around 4.64. Student life earned a solid 4.5, while value was rated a commendable 4.73. The university's weakest area, though still strong, is student life.

This institution garners exceptional scores in several key areas. Location and internationality stand out with near-perfect ratings of 4.87 and 4.85 respectively. Professors are also highly regarded at 4.73. Conversely, accommodation presents the lowest score at 3.53, indicating an area for potential improvement, although most other aspects, including student life and value, remain robust.

The university demonstrates a consistently strong performance across multiple aspects. Its location and internationality are particularly well-regarded, achieving the highest ratings. Professors and value also receive excellent scores. The weakest area appears to be accommodation, which, while still good, is rated lower than other categories. Student life and facilities are also solid, indicating a well-rounded experience.

An analysis of the provided ratings reveals a university that excels in several key areas. Facilities stand out with a score of 4.49, closely followed by Internationality and Value, both receiving 4.44. Professors and Location also score highly at 4.37. Student Life is rated well at 4.35. The lowest rated aspect is Accomodation, with a score of 4.22, suggesting this is an area for potential improvement.

Nothing to show

Overall, this institution garners consistently strong reviews across key aspects. Its strongest area is undoubtedly accommodation, receiving a perfect score, while facilities, professors, location, student life, internationality, and perceived value all achieve a solid 4 out of 5. This indicates a well-rounded university experience with a particular advantage in housing.

Across a range of metrics, the university demonstrates exceptional strengths, particularly in its Professors, Student Life, Internationality, and overall Value, all receiving perfect scores. Location, Facilities, and Accommodations also stand out with high ratings. While no specific area received a low score, the consistency across the board suggests a well-rounded institution with particularly strong offerings in teaching quality and student experience.

Reviews summary
Highlights

All 11 reviews are positive, with an average rating of 4.64/5. Students praise the high quality of professors, impressive and diverse student cohorts, and flexible learning options. The curriculum is described as relevant and contemporary, fostering significant personal and career growth.

~90% of reviews are positive, highlighting a great educational experience with diverse international students, helpful staff, and impressive internship opportunities. A small ~10% of feedback mentions dissatisfaction with course content and value for the price.

University reviews are overwhelmingly positive, with a 4.25 average rating. Students highlight competitive programs, helpful supervisors, affordable postgraduate options, and engaging campus life with many organizations. A small amount of feedback noted recent tuition increases and changes post-pandemic.

University feedback is overwhelmingly positive (~99%), with students praising the engaging academics and passionate professors. Some mention food variety and accommodation limitations.

Nothing to show

With a 4/5 average rating from one review, the student experience is highly positive (~100%). The reviewer highlights knowledgeable and supportive staff, a well-structured curriculum, and strong job placement resources.

All three reviews are highly positive, averaging 5/5 stars. Students highlight real-world business experience, including product development and profit generation, and valuable learning from industry leaders. They also praise opportunities for international collaboration and lifelong friendships.

Rating distribution
5★
64%
30%
25%
42%
0%
0%
100%
4★
36%
60%
75%
52%
0%
100%
0%
3★
0%
0%
0%
5%
0%
0%
0%
2★
0%
10%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
1★
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
Most useful review
Most liked
Just starting and very happy

I am just starting my PhD journey and I could not be happier with my choice in ISM. Amazing experience with quality professors AND impressive cohorts. Working full-time, this educational focus would not be feasible if I was not able to be flexible as to when and where I take my classes. It is a tough, long, and robust path that requires focus, but the team at ISM is truly the best. They help navigate the way that will work best for you and not put you in a 'one way fits all' situation to accomplish this massive step. I wanted a global education that was through a recognized, accredited, and respected school and ISM has not just been that, but so much more.

A fulfilling abroad experience

First of all, it was particularly easy to come to MIM, as we are guided step by step to fill papers. So first impression was pleasant and then I really kept appreciating going to class there. Teachers are nice, care for each student, seem really qualified for what they teach, and having classmates from all over the world is an unique experience. It is a real plus to study in NYC and even to have an internship there thanks to the school, although you may probably have to find it by your own.

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

Nothing to show

Loving it here!

Being here has been such a wild ride. Moving to a new country every semester and learning local languages has been both fun and challenging, but it's kinda exhausting too. Still, that hustle gives me an adrenaline rush I low-key love! The best part has been seeing our business ideas come to life and when people genuinely appreciate and engage with something we’ve built, it makes all the hard work worth it.

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our Privacy Policy for more details.
Close